Wednesday, June 30, 2010

MK Doesn't Care About His Credit, He Doesn't Want To Owe Anything To The Bank

GOT QUESTION?

I had a question regarding strategic default.

I'm living in a house that I purchased with my ex-fiancee. She's since moved out and is living in another state. I am looking at moving out of state as well, and want to get rid of my house for that reason and many others. We purchased it at 250k with an 80/20 loan, but it is currently worth about 160k. I still owe 196k to my primary mortgage and about 44k to my secondary mortgage lender. Doing the math, it seems I MIGHT break even in about about 20 years.

While I am mildly concerned about credit impact (my credit is already shot due to my ex) I am more concerned with ending up owing money to either of my lenders after a foreclosure.

I am completely willing to walk away and hand over the house, keys, deed, whatever to the banks. I just want that chapter of my life behind me.

What do I do? Who do I talk to? Are there lawyers that help with this?

GET ANSWER...

MK:

Thank you for your email. The key to turning in your “key” is to understand the consequences.

Your primary risk is as you said “owing money to either…lenders after a foreclosure”. Please consider the following:

1. If you live in a non-recourse state, then you may not be liable to the lender on the first mortgage.

Read this link about Non-Recourse and Recourse States.

2. In most situations, a second mortgage lender never receives any money after a foreclosure sale. It is likely you will be liable to the second mortgage lender for the balance due. Also, keep in mind that it is big business for third party collection agencies to purchase second mortgage at a discount (perhaps 30 cents on the dollar) and chase you for the balance. Your best bet is to contact the second mortgage lender and negotiate a discounted settlement. For example, you may offer your second mortgage lender $8,000 to settle the loan and forgive the difference. In this case the difference is $36,000 ($44,000 less $8,000). When a debt is forgiven, the forgiven amount may be considered income by the IRS. Therefore this is can be a tax liability. You will need to speak with a qualified accountant to determine if you will have any tax liability for forgiven debt.

Read this link about debt forgiveness, obligations and deficiency.

3. There are some people who file for bankruptcy in order to get rid of debt. This may be an option if you are qualified and prepared to do so. Bankruptcy can allow for the “discharge” of your unsecured debt. A bankruptcy filing stays on your credit report for 10 years. You are required to list all of your assets in a bankruptcy. If you have enough assets to satisfy all of your creditors then bankruptcy may not be an option. You will need to speak with a qualified bankruptcy attorney to determine your options.

4. You can consider deed-in-lieu of foreclosure for the first mortgage. You can negotiate with the bank by giving the deed in exchange for the full and complete satisfaction of the first mortgage debt. Of course this leaves the second mortgage still open. Your first mortgage lender may not agree to do this unless the second mortgage is taken care of. If you negotiate with your lender make sure you get everything in writing including any agreement.

5. You mentioned that you bought the property in your ex-fiancee name. This means that you may need your ex to sign off on a certain option if the property also has her name on it. You will need to speak with a qualified attorney to determine your rights and obligations.

Your other houses would be considered investment properties while the house you live in should be considered your primary residence. There are more protections in place for primary residences and not investment properties. Do not assume that the rules will be the same for investment properties as it is for your primary residence. It much harder to walk away from debt as it relates to an investment property.

Yes there are professionals who can help you. The key is to talk to several professional to determine who can work best for you.

You did the right thing by asking me. Spend some time reading the links I sent and other information on my website www.strategicdefault.org. You can use this knowledge to find the right professional or if you feel comfortable handle it own your own.

Good luck. Feel free to write back anytime.

Thank you.

Augustine A. Diji

Underwater and 90 Years Old....

GOT QUESTION?

My Parents are both in poor health and need full time assistance and care. I am currently providing the care at their home but it is becoming too much to handle and I need some help in providing for them. Our plan is to do a strategic default as their home is underwater (worth 145K owes 207K) I would rent a house in my name and my sister would live with us so she could help with providing the needed care. Their house is too small and too far away from where my sister works so her moving in at their house and helping isn't an option. With their current medical problems and at their advanced ages I suspect it means that within the next couple of years they probably will pass on, so it is painful decision but necessary. Any advice would be appreciated.

GET ANSWER…

Good Afternoon.

I am sorry to hear about your families’ situation.

Is the property in your parent’s name alone? The reason I ask is this. If you decided to strategically default then the borrower of the mortgage loan and the owner of the property face certain consequences.

· It will negatively impact their credit score.

· It will expose them to a possible deficiency judgment. A deficiency judgment is an unsecured money judgment against a borrower whose mortgage foreclosure sale did not produce sufficient funds to pay the underlying promissory note or mortgage loan, in full. Please click this link to learn more about deficiency judgments and debt obligations.

· Their peace of mind and space will be disturbed by collection calls, letters, and perhaps visits.

Based on what you have told me, I do not believe that your parents will be concerned about their credit score. However, if they have savings, stocks, bonds, or other assets then a deficiency judgment can be an issue. Any debt incurred by your parents may stay with your parents even after they pass on. If you live in a state that do not allow for deficiency judgments then this may not be an issue. A state that does not allow for deficiency judgments is called a non-recourse state.

You may also consider contacting the bank and telling them about the situation. You can tell the bank that your parents want to give the property to the bank in exchange for the complete and full satisfaction of all of the debt that is owed to the bank. This is called a deed-in-lieu of foreclosure. This will eliminate any deficiency judgment risk to your parents. The key is to get any agreement with the bank in writing.

Do you parents have a will? What about a health care proxy or a medical directive? I recommend you speak to an estate attorney and discuss these matters in detail. A will lays out the plan for the distribution of your parents’ personal property and real estate. The health care proxy or medical directive allow your parents to entrust their health care decisions with you or other family member, if your parents are unable to make health decision for themselves.

Focus on what’s best for your parents. Also, you need income to take care of your parent’s health and for your needs. So it can make sense to use the mortgage payments for family needs instead of paying on a worthless property.

I do not believe it makes any sense to put money into a house that has no value. Also, do you want to inherit the house?

First things first. Focus on the needs of your parents and yourself. Then be clear about the risks of strategically defaulting. As I mentioned before the primary risk is any deficiency judgment your parents may be exposed to.

I wish you and your family well.

Please write me with any questions.

Thank you.

Augustine A. Diji

Monday, June 21, 2010

JS Can't Pay A Student Loan & Sallie Mae Is Taking Her Tax Refund

GOT QUESTIONS?

I went to school back in 2005. I attended Lehigh Valley College, during second semester found out that they were going to forcefully shut down or be sold due to money scams with Sallie Mae to get more money from students and the courses not being creditable. I have my student loan through Sallie Mae. At the end of 2nd semester i stopped attending. I have been unemployeed since the end of 2008 and have three children under the age of three. I have not been able to make my loan payments and Sallie Mae has already took my total tax return from last year. Was just wondering if there is anything I can do cause I really can't afford to pay my loans. I can't even get a job cause i don't have a car and where I live we need a car. I was planning to buy one with my tax return so I could go back to work but Sallie Mae had taken the whole return. I don't know if there is anything I can do, and if so how I go about doing it. Thank you and I appreciate any info you have. Thank you JS

GET ANSWER….

Dear JS:

Thank you for writing to me.

Unfortunately you are in a difficult situation. Sallie Mae has the right to collect on the loan using every legally available means. You should consult with an attorney or a non-profit legal services organization regarding your allegations of fraud involving Lehigh Valley College and Sallie Mae.
These are some of your options:

• Contact Sallie Mae and enter into a forbearance or reduced payment agreement. You can request that they stop all collection efforts until you find a suitable job. Once you do find a job then you can ask for reduced payments. You can ask Sallie Mae not to take any future tax refunds. Of course, if there is an agreement it must be in writing.

Please try this link to learn about different options for repayment: http://studentaid.ed.gov/PORTALSWebApp/students/english/difficulty.jsp

• Normally bankruptcy does not discharge a student loan, however there is an exception to discharging student loans. A student loan can be discharged if there is a provable undue hardship. Undue hardship is defined as the permanent physical inability to work. You must prove in bankruptcy court that:

o You’re physically unable to work
o You’re likely to be unable to work for most of the loan term
o You’ve made a good faith effort to repay the debt
o Paying it would prevent you, your spouse, and your dependents from maintaining a “minimal” standard of living.

You need to consult with a qualified bankruptcy attorney to see if you can qualify.

• There are also loan forgiveness programs. The Public Service Loan Forgiveness Program was created to encourage individuals to enter and continue to work full-time in public service jobs. Under this program, you may qualify for forgiveness of the remaining balance due on your eligible federal student loans after you have made 120 payments on loans under certain repayment plans while employed full time by certain public service employers. You can go to this link to learn more.

http://studentaid.ed.gov/PORTALSWebApp/students/english/PSF.jsp

So stay strong. I believe something will work out for you.

Thank you.

Sunday, June 20, 2010

J Considers Selling The Deed To His Property

Got Questions?

My wife and I are considering a strategic default. Recently, I came across an article that referenced the Wilshire Holding Group, and a service (Fresh Start Housing Program) that they provide to those
considering the SD option. I am curious if you have ever reviewed this program and if you have, what is your opinion of this service? Your input would be greatly appreciated!

Thanks,

J.

Get Answers…

Dear J.

Before I discuss Wilshire the first question you and your wife need to ask is…What Are You Trying To Achieve?

This is the first I have heard of Wilshire Holding Groups and it’s fresh start housing program. Let me say that my comments are based upon a reading of Wilshire’s website. I have not talked with any person at the company. I have not talked with any of their clients.

Wilshire states in their website “Wilshire purchases your property and assumes the loan(s) subject to your original agreement.” Essentially, this means Wilshire will take title or deed to the property. Since they state they will “assume [your] loan”, it seems to us that they will not immediately pay off your mortgage loan. Despite the fact the mortgage loan will still remain in your name. We do not advocate giving up title or a deed to your property without your mortgage balance being paid in full at the same time.

Why does Willshire need your deed or title to your home to help you? Each strategy discussed on Willshire’s website can be achieved without giving up a deed or title to your property.

My recommendation: Ask Wilshire to put their entire proposal with guarantees in writing. Ask how much you will receive to sell your property? Ask what happens if Wilshire is unable to successfully negotiate with your lender? What will happen if Wilshire is unable to get the lender to forgive any amounts due on your mortgage? Will you be stuck with the liability even though you “sold” the property to Wilshire? Ask Wilshire to send you the details of 3 recently completed deals?

You should then take the information and have it reviewed by an attorney in your jurisdiction before you make any decision.

A deed to a piece of property is the ultimate symbol of wealth ownership. If you sign your deed for nothing, you get nothing.

CS In Oregon Needs Guidance

GOT QUESTIONS?

Hello,

I'm looking for some guidance in regards to doing a strategic default or not. Live in Bend Oregon (one of the most inflated housing markets in the US before the crash). Purchased our single family residence in May 08 for 375,000, 20% down. Balance on our first is $293,000, no second or LOC. Current estimates of the property is 200-225K. Prices appears to still be falling, but at a much lower rate than they were. I've spoken with a real estate attorney who says Oregon is a non-recourse state and we would not have any tax implications with doing a default.

Looking at the prospect of being able to live in the house for 12-18 months rent free would allow us to pocket nearly $25,000, good seed money towards the purchase of a new house in 5 years when we would be eligible for a new loan.

Appreciate the website, great resource!

GET ANSWERS…

Thanks for reaching out and thank you for your kind words.

It is generally true. You can rebuild your credit over time.

If your attorney is correct about you not having any tax implications or recourse implications in your home state of Oregon then there appears to be little risk of any deficiency judgment or forgiveness of debt. You should ask your attorney if the lender has the option of foregoing a foreclosure action in favor of pursuing a legal action for a personal money judgment for the money loaned to purchase the home.

Please read this article so you have a clear understanding about debt obligations, deficiency, and forgiveness. What You Need To Know About Debt Forgiveness, Obligations, and Deficiency.

The key question is can you live in your property for up to 12 to 18 months. You should speak to your attorney about what it will take to achieve this and what it will cost to defend a foreclosure action and other creditor actions.

We advocate the use of strategic default if it fits a person’s unique set of circumstances. The primary purpose of a strategic default are cash flow protection, wealth preservation and savings preservation. It is our belief that it does not make economic sense to put money into a worthless asset that has little chance of gaining value. Furthermore, you can invest the money into better uses and, if need be, have a cushion to pay any creditor.

Remember, the decision to strategically default can take days or weeks. It takes months or years for the full implementation of it. Be prepared for your lender’s collection efforts. It can take all forms, including calls, letters, and perhaps a visit. Your attorney will tell you that a lender must follow the law regarding all collection efforts.

Focus on what you want to achieve. Make sure to weight the benefits and the risks. In the end, if the benefits outweigh the risks then you should strongly consider a strategic default.



Monday, June 7, 2010

W Wants To Default On Old House and Buy A New House - What's The Risk?

GOT QUESTIONS?

My wife and I have been trying to sell our home for nearly a year. We have had little or no traffic no matter how much I lower the price. We CAN afford the payments, it's just that the home has become way too small for our family size.

I have been pre-approved for another loan on a much larger house with the payments being almost identical. This would be a new build and the loan would be in place before I defaulted on my current mortgage. I was approved to carry both mortgages.

What are the consequences besides taking a credit hit if I default? My wife and I are both over 750 credit rating. Are there any other options for my situation?

GET ANSWERS…..

If you default, in addition to the negative impact to your credit score, you may be responsible for a deficiency. A deficiency is the difference between what a lender is owed on a mortgage and what it receives. I will explain this in more detail later.

If you want to keep your credit intact, you may consider selling the property at loss and covering any short fall out of pocket. For example, if you find a buyer for your home at $400,000 and your closing costs including the money you owe the bank are $425,000, then you can come up with the $25,000 short fall at closing. Another alternative is you can look for a tenant for current property to cover the monthly carrying costs when you decide to move. You may have to cover the difference from the rental amount and the carrying expenses. Of course, the key questions are: how long are you willing to carry the house and when will you be able to sell the house?.

If you decided to default, you have various options.

You can utilize a short sale, deed-in-lieu, loan modification or let the property go to foreclosure sale. All of these options will negatively impact your credit and will expose you to a possible deficiency.

A short sale occurs when a lender let’s you sell your property for an amount less than what is owed on the mortgage. Essentially your lender may be willing to accept less than the full amount due on a mortgage. If you owe the lender $400,000 then the lender may agree to let you sell the property for $350,000. Keep in mind that the $50,000 difference will become a deficiency. A deficiency balance can be forgiven or it can become a judgment. If the deficiency is forgiven then there may be a tax liability. The lender may refuse to forgive the deficiency and instead seek a deficiency judgment. This is a legal judgment obtain by a lender after filing the proper legal paperwork in court. If the lender successfully obtain a deficiency judgment then the lender has the right to seize the cash in your bank accounts, garnish wages, or place a lien on personal property, business assets or real estate.

A deed-in-lieu is when you enter into a written agreement to give the property back to the bank. The key is to negotiate a full settlement of your total outstanding mortgage debt including fees and penalties in exchange for the deed to your property.

You may be able to modify the loan for a lower payment or a reduction in the principle balance.

If you let the property go to foreclosure sale then the lender will sell your property at an auction. If the lender takes the property back then you will not have any deficiency. If the lender sells the property at auction for less than what is owed then there will be a deficiency.

You may not owe a deficiency in certain circumstances. The Federal Mortgage Debt Relief Act provides relief to homeowners from paying taxes on any forgiven debt. Also certain states have anti-deficiency statues. This means that state law prevents a lender from pursing a borrower for any debt deficiency. A state that prevents a lender from pursing a borrower for any debt deficiency is called a non-recourse state.

Please read the following articles and posts. This will help you significantly.

What You Need To Know About Debt Forgiveness, Obligations, and Deficiency.http://ezinearticles.com/?What-Everyone-Should-Know-About-Debt-Forgiveness,-Obligations-and-Deficiency&id=3737575

Recourse and Non-Recourse State:http://www.strategicdefault.org/2010/02/what-is-difference-between-non-recourse.html

Bottom line. Your primary risk is any deficiency.

If you have any question please feel free to contact me.

Augustine Diji

Tuesday, June 1, 2010

JH Seek Advice For Her Son - How Do You Start The Strategic Default Process?

GOT QUESTIONS

My son has a home in Davenport, Florida which he paid $189,900 for in
2005. It is now worth about $70,000 according to a respected Realtor
in the area. How can he start the "strategic default" process? He
has a first and a second on the house and quit making payments on the
first in October, 2009 and on the second in February, 2010. (Dates are
approximate) The first is held by Chase and the second by Bank of
America.

GET ANSWERS....

Well technically he started the strategic default process the moment he stopped making payments. Your son had the money to pay but did not want to waste the cash on a worthless asset or did not have the ability to pay.

Here are some initial questions:

What does your son want to achieve? Is he looking for a loan modification or principle reduction? Has he talked to the bank? Does he want to let the property go with the least exposure? Does he live in the property or is it an investment rental? Does he need time to live in the property before moving? Does he know that it can take a year or more to complete a foreclosure in Florida?

At this point his options are: Foreclosure, Deed-In-Lieu, Short Sale, Bankruptcy & Loan Modification. All of these options will negatively affect his credit score in difference ways. Obviously at this point since he stopped paying his credit should not really be an issue. It is my opinion that he should choose the option that provides the least financial exposure after he strategically defaults. The issue of bankruptcy is that it stays on your credit for 10 years and there are certain financial requirements (“means test”) to qualify. Your son should speak with a qualified attorney if he is exploring the bankruptcy option.

I ask all of my readers to read this article: What Everyone Should Know About Debt Forgiveness Obligations and Deficiency

One of the most important aspects of strategic default is to understand the consequences of any remaining debt (deficiency) after a strategic default.

Your son’s number one goal should be to minimize the financial after effects after the strategic default. This means his goal is to owe the lender little or no money after he has let go of the house.

Keep in mind that in most circumstances the second mortgage never gets satisfied no matter what plan your son decides to implement. He must be prepared to negotiate a deal with the second mortgage lender so the debt does not follow him.

Take some time to read the Got Questions? Get Answers. These are posts of my reader’s questions and answers to them. The information can help you.

Most importantly, make sure your son understands that strategic defaults are not measured in days or months. It is measured in years. He needs to be prepared for the letters, phone calls, and collection harassment. In time it will work out for him.